top of page

Should a Small Business Use an AI Receptionist or Hire Another Person First?

Writer: Zh Dast Sari
Zh Dast Sari
Oct 21
6 min read

Should a small business use an AI receptionist or hire another person first? That question came up in four separate reports this week, and the owners answering it were clear: most of them try AI first, then decide if they still need the hire.


FreshBooks published the sharpest number on October 13. In a Wakefield Research survey of 500 solopreneurs and microbusiness owners, 86% said that when a task is too much for them alone, they try AI before they hire anyone. And when asked what mattered more for the future of their business, 64% picked looking bigger and more capable than they actually are. Only 36% picked simply getting more done.


That 64% number rings true to me. A one-person shop does not lose work because the owner is lazy. It loses work at 7:40 p.m., when the shop is closed, the owner is at dinner, and a new customer gets voicemail. Looking capable, for a small business, often just means somebody picks up.


The phone problem, in plain numbers


BT Business launched its own AI Receptionist in Britain this month, and it published the research behind the launch. Censuswide surveyed 1,500 decision-makers at UK small and medium businesses in late September.


Two-thirds of them — 67% — said they miss at least one call on an average day that they believe costs them business. BT puts the total loss across UK small businesses at £3.7 billion a year.


The rest of the survey reads like a diary of a busy owner:


- 58% spend between 30 minutes and two hours a day answering customer calls.

- 85% said those calls interrupt their other work.

- On the customer side, 75% of callers give a business three tries before they give up.

- 58% of callers said they would tell friends and family to avoid a business that did not pick up.


Three tries. Then they tell their friends.


That is why I keep coming back to the line we use at NexAIS (https://www.nexais.ca/): a missed call can be a missed customer. It is not a slogan we invented for a brochure. It is what these numbers describe, week after week, in country after country.


What the Federal Reserve found underneath the optimism


On October 8, researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York published a calmer piece of work. They used the 2025 Small Business Credit Survey, which covered more than 5,200 employer firms, and compared what AI users expect next year with what non-users expect.


AI users were far more upbeat. On revenue, the share expecting an increase beat the share expecting a decrease by 48 percentage points among AI users, compared with 21 points among non-users. On hiring, AI users had a 33-point net expectation of adding staff, against 15 points for non-users.


Read that second number again. The businesses using AI were the ones more likely to expect to hire people, not fewer of them.


The researchers were careful. This is expectation, not proof that AI caused the growth. But the pattern held even after they accounted for firm size, owner age, past results, and how healthy the business said it was. It held most strongly for firms that said they were struggling with technology in the first place.


That matches what I see building AVA, our AI receptionist at NexAIS. Owners do not ask me how to replace their staff. They ask how to stop losing the calls that come in while their staff are busy doing the actual work — the haircut, the furnace repair, the consultation. AVA answers around the clock, books the appointment, takes the lead's details, sends an SMS follow-up, and keeps the history so a returning caller is recognised, not treated like a stranger. The human still does the job. The machine just stops the job from walking away at the ringing stage.


The warning buried in the Pax8 report


Not everything this week was cheerful, and the most useful report was the uncomfortable one.


Pax8 released its Q3 2026 SMB AI Pulse Report on October 12, based on 1,150 small-business leaders in the US, UK, Germany, and Sweden. Two-thirds of businesses already using AI said they had built at least one AI solution that is now in regular use. Good for them.


Then the other numbers:


- 35% found AI tools, workflows, or agents running in their business that nobody had approved.

- 49% of businesses that paid for AI got at least one bill higher than they expected.

- 55% of decision-makers said they personally spend three or more hours a week checking, editing, or correcting AI work.


There is the real cost owners do not budget for. Not the subscription. The supervision. The surprise invoice. The tool a well-meaning employee set up on a personal account, with customer names inside it, that nobody in charge has ever seen.


I run my own spending with a hard monthly ceiling for exactly this reason, and my rule for clients is the same one I use at home: know what it costs, know where the data sits, know who can see it. If a vendor cannot answer those three questions in plain language, the product is not ready for your customers, whatever the demo looked like.


This is also why flat pricing matters more than vendors admit. AVA is Starter at $197 a month, Professional at $399, and Grow at $599 (https://crm.nexais.ca/pricing/ai-receptionist). No per-minute meter running while a chatty customer tells a long story. No bill that doubles in your busiest month — which, cruel detail, is the month you needed the help most. The 49% in the Pax8 report who got a surprise bill were not careless. They bought a pricing model designed to surprise them.


So: AI first, or hire first?


Here is the order I give every owner who asks, including the ones who do not buy from me.


First, count the calls you are losing. Not a guess. Check your phone records for a week. If the honest answer is two or three real enquiries a week going to voicemail, that is your test case, and it is big enough.


Second, try AI on those calls only. A front desk is the safest place to start because the work is narrow: answer, understand what the caller wants, book or take a message, write it down where you can see it. Our own entry point is a free 7-day pilot on real calls — that is the only offer we make below the Starter plan, because an owner should hear the thing on her own phone line before she pays a cent. You can hear AVA yourself any time at +1 (437) 529-0400. It answers at 3 p.m. and at 3 a.m. with the same patience.


Third, keep a note of every lead in one place. Call notes scattered across sticky notes and personal phones are how the Pax8 shadow-AI problem starts. Put the record in a proper CRM from day one — HubSpot CRM is a reasonable free-to-start option for a small team — and make sure your phone system writes into it, not beside it.


Fourth, hire for the work AI exposed, not the work it replaced. If the phone starts bringing in more booked jobs than you can handle, congratulations, you now have a real hiring problem — too much work. That is the hire the New York Fed numbers are pointing at. Hire the technician, the stylist, the associate. Let the machine keep answering the phone.


One honest limit


AI will not fix a business whose problem is not the phone. If callers reach you fine and still do not buy, you have a pricing problem or a trust problem, and a polite robot voice will not save you. I would rather tell an owner that in the first call than sell her a plan she cancels in month two. Churn helps nobody, least of all a small vendor whose name is on the contract.


But if your problem is the ringing phone nobody can get to — while you are under a car, on a ladder, mid-appointment, or simply closed — the evidence this week is hard to argue with. Owners are trying AI first. Eighty-six percent of them. The ones using it expect to grow and to hire. The ones missing calls are paying for the silence already, at £3.7 billion a year in one country alone.


The only choice left is whether you pay for the silence, or pay less to end it.


Questions about how this would work on your own line? Our contact page (https://www.nexais.ca/contact) reaches a real person on our team in Richmond Hill.



Disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend tools we genuinely believe help small businesses.


Sources


- FreshBooks / Wakefield Research, "The Era of the Solopreneur" — reported by Intelligent SME.tech (https://www.intelligentsme.tech/2026/10/13/before-they-hire-86-of-solopreneurs-try-ai-first-freshbooks-survey-finds/) (October 13, 2026)

- BT Business AI Receptionist launch and Censuswide survey of 1,500 UK SME decision-makers — Telecoms Tech News (https://www.telecomstechnews.com/news/bt-business-launches-ai-receptionist-for-customer-calls/) and WebWire (https://www.webwire.com/ViewPressRel.asp?aId=361333) (October 2, 2026)

- Federal Reserve Bank of New York, "AI Adoption and Employment Expectations: Evidence from a Survey of Small Business Owners" — Liberty Street Economics (https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2026/10/ai-adoption-and-employment-expectations-evidence-from-a-survey-of-small-business-owners/) (October 8, 2026)

- Pax8 Q3 2026 SMB AI Pulse Report (1,150 SMB leaders) — GlobeNewswire (https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2026/10/12/3378898/0/en/pax8-research-finds-small-businesses-are-building-ai-faster-than-they-can-govern-it.html) (October 12, 2026)

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


nexais-logo-full-horizontal-C1ABDukH.png

© 2026 NexAIS Inc. All rights reserved.

bottom of page